Retail vs Market vs Trade Value for Car Insurance

When you insure a car in South Africa you usually choose how it is valued: retail value (what a dealer would sell it for), market value (roughly the average of retail and trade), or trade value (what a dealer would pay you for it). Retail pays out the most and costs the most to insure; trade pays out the least. The value basis decides what you actually get if your car is written off or stolen, so it is worth choosing deliberately.

What is the difference between retail, market and trade value?

Retail value is the price a dealer would charge to sell your car, so it is the highest figure. Trade value is what a dealer would pay to buy it from you, so it is the lowest. Market value sits in between, roughly the average of the two. Your policy schedule states which basis your cover uses, and that single line has a big effect on any payout.

Which value should I insure my car for?

It depends on your budget and how you would replace the car. Retail value gives the biggest payout and the best chance of buying a similar replacement, but the premium is higher. Trade value is cheaper each month but pays out less. Many drivers choose retail for peace of mind on a financed or newer car, where a shortfall would hurt most.

How does the value basis affect a write-off or theft payout?

Directly. If your car is written off or stolen, the insurer pays out based on your agreed value basis, less your excess and any outstanding conditions. On a retail basis you receive the retail figure at the time of loss; on a trade basis you receive the lower trade figure. On many cars that gap runs into tens of thousands of rand.

Does the payout use the value when I took out the policy or when I claim?

When you claim. These values are not fixed. Your car depreciates over time, so the retail, market or trade figure used at a claim reflects the car's value on the day of the loss, not the day you bought the policy. This is why a payout can be lower than you expected on an older car, and why it is worth reviewing your cover each year.

What if I still owe money on the car?

If you financed the car, the payout goes first to settle the outstanding finance. If you owe more than the insured value, you face a shortfall, which is where credit shortfall (gap) cover helps. Choosing retail value reduces the risk of a shortfall compared with trade value, because the payout starts from a higher figure.

The bottom line

Retail, market and trade value decide what you actually receive if your car is lost, so choose the basis on purpose, not by default. Check which one is on your schedule, and weigh the higher premium of retail against the bigger payout. Compare cover and value options before you settle.

Cover depends on your policy schedule and wording, and Savvy Insurance is a comparison service. Always refer to your own policy documents for exactly what is and is not covered.

← Back to all articles